@c -*-texinfo-*-
@c This is part of the XEmacs Lisp Reference Manual.
@c Copyright (C) 2001 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
@c See the file lispref.texi for copying conditions.

@setfilename ../../info/packaging.info

@c Macro to make formatting of the XEmacs pms name consistent.
@c Maybe @sc looks OK in HTML?  If so, condition on Info.
@iftex
@set xpms XE@sc{macs} Packaging System
@end iftex
@ifnottex
@set xpms XEmacs Packaging System
@end ifnottex

@node Packaging, Lisp Data Types, Introduction, Top
@chapter The @value{xpms}
@cindex package
@cindex packaging

The XEmacs distribution, starting with version 21, comes only with a
very basic set of built-in modes and libraries.  Most of the libraries
that were part of the distribution of earlier versions of XEmacs are now
available separately.  The user as well as the system administrator can
choose which packages to install; the actual installation process is
easy.  This gives an installer the ability to tailor an XEmacs
installation for local needs with safe removal of unnecessary code.

This chapter describes how to package Lisp libraries for use with the
@value{xpms}.

@emph{Please note carefully} that the term @dfn{package} as used in
XEmacs refers to an aggregation of Lisp code and/or data distributed as
a unit.  It does not, as it does in many Lisps, refer to a way of
creating separate name spaces.  XEmacs has no facility for providing
separate name spaces.  (If we ever do get separate name spaces, we'll
probably regret overloading the nomenclature in this way, but it's
become established.)

@menu
Introduction:
* Package Overview::            Lisp Libraries and Packages.

Packaging Lisp Libraries:
* Package Terminology::         Basic stuff.
* Building Packages::           Turn packaged source into a tarball.
* Makefile Targets::            Package @file{Makefile} targets
* Local.rules File::            Tell the @value{xpms} about your host.
* Creating Packages::           Tell the @value{xpms} about your package.
* Documenting Packages::        Explain your package to users and hackers.
@c * History::                     History of the @value{xpms}
@c * Installation::                Installing the @value{xpms} with your (X)Emacs.
@c * Configuration::               Configuring the @value{xpms} for use.
@c * Usage::                       An overview of the operation of the @value{xpms}.
@c * Bug Reports::                 Reporting Bugs and Problems
@c * Frequently Asked Questions::  Questions and answers from the mailing list.

Internals and Package Release Engineering:
* Issues::                      
@end menu

@node Package Overview, Package Terminology, , Packaging
@chapter An overview of the @value{xpms}

The @value{xpms} is a system for administering the installation, upgrade, and
removal of Lisp libraries.  For the end user, it provides facilities for
determining availability of packages and which versions at remote
sites.  It will download and automatically install a package, ensuring
that any old files from previous versions of the package are removed
first.  By providing a standard set of hierarchies for installation, it
makes configuration of XEmacs simpler.  Furthermore, packages normally
provide ancillary auto-autoloads and custom-loads libraries, which are
automatically detected and loaded by XEmacs upon startup.  This means
that once installed, all facilities of package, including autoloading
the library upon invocation of a command provided by the library and
convenient configuration and customization, are automatically available
to the user.  There is no need to add autoloads or keybindings to in the
init file, and structured configuration of the package is available
through the Customize system even before the libraries are loaded.

All of this convenience comes at a cost.  The cost of administration at
the package level is negligible compared to the benefits, of course.
However, the requirement that XEmacs find and load auto-autoloads and
custom-loads libraries comes at a fairly large cost in startup time.  In
order to reduce this cost, XEmacs imposes fairly strict conditions on
the structure of an installed package.

Meeting these requirements, as well as simply providing the
auto-autoloads and the information about availability and so on does
impose some costs on the library maintainer.  The @value{xpms} also provides
structure and utilities to the library maintainer to make these tasks
easier.  This manual documents the requirements and the tools that the
@value{xpms} provides to ensure that a package satisfies them.

@menu
* The User View::
* The Library Maintainer View::
* The Package Release Engineer View::
@end menu


@node The User View, The Library Maintainer View, , Package Overview
@section The User View

@strong{N.B.}  Much of the discussion in this section undoubtedly
belongs elsewhere, @ref{Packages,,,xemacs}.

From the user's point of view, an XEmacs binary package is simply a
standard tarball (usually gzipped) containing Lisp sources, compiled
Lisp, documentation, and possibly data files or supporting executables.
The tarball is unpacked using standard tools such as GNU tar and gzip.
The package system does impose certain requirements for automatic
configuration to work.

Here the main consideration is that the tarball ``expects'' to be
unpacked from the top of a package hierarchy.  A @dfn{package hierarchy}
is basically an image of a classic Emacs ``run-in-place'' tree, with
@file{lisp}, @file{etc}, @file{info}, @file{man}, @file{lib-src}, and
@file{pkginfo} subdirectories of the top.  The @file{pkginfo}
subdirectory is for use by the @value{xpms} administration tools, and
currently contains a @file{MANIFEST.@var{package-name}} file for each
package to ensure that no cruft remains when a package is removed or
updated.  The @file{lisp}, @file{etc}, and @file{lib-src} subdirectories
are further subdivided, with a subdirectory for each package.  The
@file{info} directory obeys the usual conventions.
@emph{I.e.}, the @file{info} directory is flat
with a(n) (optional) @file{dir} file and one (set of) info file(s) per
package.  The @file{man} subdirectory typically contains documentation
sources, separated by package.  (It does not contain @file{man(1)}
pages, as Emacs provides very few of them.)

There are several standard package hierarchies, and administrators can
configure others at build time, while users can configure others at run
time.  The standard system hierarchies are all subdirectories of an
@c #### This is possibly incorrect usage of "installation root."
XEmacs installation root, typically @file{/usr/local/lib/xemacs/}.
These are the @file{xemacs-packages}, @file{mule-packages},
@file{infodock-packages}, and @file{site-packages} hierarchies.  Each
has the structure described above, but the purposes differ.  The
@file{xemacs-packages} is the normal place for installing ``official''
packages and many third-party libraries.  Unfortunately, it is not yet
quite possible to read libraries containing international characters
with a non-Mule XEmacs, so such libraries are sequestered in the
@file{mule-packages} hierarchy.  Some packages are compatible only with
the Infodock development environment, and they will be installed in the
@file{infodock-packages} hierarchy.  The @file{site-packages} hierarchy
is for packages not distributed by XEmacs.org, typically locally
developed.

Packages are in principle supposed to be XEmacs version-independent, but
if such dependencies are unavoidable, additional standard package
hierarchies may be installed under version directories, @emph{e.g.}
@file{/usr/local/lib/xemacs-21.4.6/}.

Users who do not have sufficient privilege to install packages in the
system hierarchies may install package hierarchies under @file{~/.xemacs}.
At present only the @file{xemacs-packages}, @file{mule-packages}, and
@file{site-packages} hierarchies are supported, but it might make sense to
extend this to support @file{infodock-packages} hierarchies in the future.

The package hierarchies are not searched directly for libraries to be
loaded; this would be very costly.  Instead, the hierarchies are ordered
according to certain rules, and searched for package lisp directories at
invocation.  These directories are added to the general
@code{load-path}.  As usual, it is @code{load-path} that is searched at
run-time.  This approach is somewhat costly at initialization, but
results in a very ``clean'' @code{load-path}.

The order of search can be changed at build time by specifying the
@samp{--with-user-packages} (an alias for @samp{--with-early-packages}),
@samp{--with-system-packages} (an alias for
@samp{--with-late-packages}), and @samp{--with-legacy-packages} (an
alias for @samp{--with-last-packages}) options to @file{configure}, or
at run-time by specifying the @code{EMACSEARLYPACKAGES},
@code{EMACSLATEPACKAGES}, @code{EMACSLASTPACKAGES} environment
variables.  @xref{Packages,,,xemacs}.

@c #### The following description is quite possibly inaccurate.
@c Please, Michael, write some specs up!
The default order of search is hierarchically determined.  First, the
roots are ordered.  The @dfn{early} roots are the user-specific roots,
typically @file{~/.xemacs}.  The @dfn{late} roots are the system roots,
typically @file{/usr/local/lib/xemacs-21.4.6} and
@file{/usr/local/lib/xemacs}, in that order.  All hierarchies for a
given root are searched for package Lisp directories, which are appended
to @code{load-path} in the order found.  Then the search proceeds to the
next root, whose results will be appended to the @code{load-path}
generated by previous roots.

Second, the hierarchies below each root are searched in the order
@file{site-packages}, @file{infodock-packages}, @file{mule-packages},
then @file{xemacs-packages}.

In each hierarchy there should be a @file{lisp} subdirectory, containing
directories named for the packages.  Each package's Lisp libraries thus
are contained in a directory of the form
@var{root}/@var{hierarchy}/lisp/@var{package}/.

With such a complex search algorithm, the possibility of libraries being
shadowed by another library with the same name is quite real.  There are
two considerations here.  First, every XEmacs package contains certain
libraries with constant names.  These are

@table @file
@item _pkg.el
Lisp code to inform the package administration system about the package

@item auto-autoloads.el
Lisp code to set up autoloaded functions and variables that may be
needed at load time

@item custom-load.el
definitions of configuration variables for use with the Customize
system.
@end table

They are special-cased, because the way they are used prevents shadowing
from being an issue.

Second, it is possible that multiple copies of some library, or
different libraries with the same name, are installed in various places
in the hierarchies.  To detect such shadows, use
@code{list-load-path-shadows}.

Finally, note that most basic Emacs functionality, including most of the
Lisp API, is implemented in Lisp libraries.  Because they use internal
reserved APIs that are subject to change according the needs of the
developers, these libraries are distributed with the XEmacs binary, and
are called @dfn{core Lisp libraries}.  Most core Lisp libraries are
``preloaded'' into the Emacs binary and in normal usage are never
explicitly loaded.  However, they can be explicitly loaded, and if so
they are searched on @code{load-path}.
@c #### Is this correct?  It is not for C-h f, for example.
Furthermore, functions such as @code{locate-library} will also search on
the @code{load-path}.  The searching takes place under somewhat
different rules from those used for packaged Lisp.  It is probably
easiest to think of the package hierarchy searching algorithm as
receiving a @code{load-path} initialized to the core Lisp directories.


@node The Library Maintainer View, The Package Release Engineer View, The User View, Package Overview
@section The Library Maintainer View

From the library maintainer's viewpoint, the advantages to the @value{xpms}
stem from the convenience to the user of installation and upgrade.
Since an installed package automatically registers its entry points via
autoload and its configuration variables with the Customize system,
configuration FAQs are reduced.  When it's easy to upgrade, users learn
to try @samp{Tools | Packages | Update Installed Packages} before
posting a FAQ whose answer is ``long since fixed, please upgrade.''

This comes at some cost, as the library maintainer needs to arrange that
the package be installed in a directory structure that satisfies the
requirements of the @value{xpms}.  Autoload cookies and defcustoms must also
be added to existing libraries.  The @value{xpms} provides infrastructure to
assure that all of these annoyances need only be dealt with once.  The
autoload cookies and defcustoms are beyond the scope of this chapter, but
most maintainers of modern packages are already familiar with these
mechanisms.

The @value{xpms} may be divided into the @dfn{infrastructure} common to all
packages, and the package-specific @dfn{control files}.  The
infrastructure supports global builds, installation, and generation of
the ``sumo'' bundles of packages, as well as generation of individual
packages.  The package control files describe the structure of the
package's source tree and provide administrative information.

@menu
* Infrastructure::              Global Makefiles and common rules.
* Control Files::               Package-specific Makefiles and administrative files.
* Obtaining::                   Obtaining the @value{xpms} and required utilities.
@end menu

@node Infrastructure, Control Files, , The Library Maintainer View
@subsection Infrastructure

In order to get the greatest benefit from the @value{xpms}, a library
maintainer should place the package sources in an appropriate place in
the XEmacs source package hierarchy, and arrange to have the source
package imported into the XEmacs CVS repository.
@c #### the parenthetical remark should go to "issues."
(We realize that the
latter requirement can be quite burdensome.  We are working on ways to
remove this requirement, but for the present it remains necessary.)  The
library maintainer must also keep sources for any packages his/her
package requires.  This requirement is somewhat burdensome, but unlikely
to be relaxed because of the implementation of compilation of macros in
Emacs Lisp.  Macros cannot be called by compiled Lisp (the macro
expansion, which is always known at compile time, is inlined), so the
source of the macro must be loaded before compiling the called function.

The source package hierarchy may be rooted anywhere.  The CVS module is
called ``packages,'' so we will refer to the top directory of the source
package hierarchy as ``the @file{packages} directory.''  The
@file{packages} directory contains two source subdirectories,
@file{xemacs-packages} and @file{mule-packages} (for convenience in
segregating the packages which depend on Mule, as they will cause
load-time errors in a non-Mule XEmacs).  Each subdirectory contains many
package source directories, whose internal structure is not specified.
That structure is left up to the convenience of the library maintainers.
The requirements on the top directory of an individual package source
tree are given below, @ref{Control Files}.

The @file{packages} directory contains some auxiliary Lisp libraries
used in the compilation and packaging process.  The content of these
libraries is of interest primarily to the packaging engineers, @ref{The 
Package Release Engineer View}.

Finally, the @file{packages}, @file{packages/xemacs-packages}, and
@file{packages/mule-packages} directories contain @file{Makefile}s and
include files to control the package creation process.  The
@file{Makefile}s in @file{packages/xemacs-packages} and
@file{packages/mule-packages} simply define the default sets of known
packages and include @file{../iterate.rules}, which implements recursive
building of all target packages.

The @samp{make} infrastructure in @file{packages} includes

@table @file
@item Makefile
controls building of individual packages, local installation, and
bundling of ``sumo'' tarballs

@item iterate.rules
controls recursive builds of multiple packages

@item meta-iterate.rules
This is used by higher-level subdirectories that do not directly
contain packages.  Subdirectories directly containing packages should
use iterate.rules instead.

@item XEmacs.rules
provides the rules for building and packaging.  Included by all package
@file{Makefile}s.

@item Local.rules
provides local configuration, such as installation targets and staging
directories, as well as a number of kludges (many now obsolete) required
for building packages on the Windows platform.

@item Local.rules.template
a template for Local.rules, liberally commented

@item Local.rules.mk
consistency checking for @file{Local.rules}, included by both the
top-level @file{Makefile} and by @file{XEmacs.rules}.

@item Local.rules.inc
a file to @code{include} in package @file{Makefile}s to be able to get
at variables in @file{Local.rules} @emph{before} including
@file{XEmacs.rules}. 

@c #### Add to "issues"
@item package-compile.el
compile environment (@emph{e.g.}, load-path) setup.
@end table

Of these, only @file{Local.rules} and @file{package-compile.el} need to
be modified by the library maintainer.  The changes to Local.rules
affect only your environment.  This should need to be done only once
when first preparing the source environment.  The necessary
modifications to @file{package-compile.el} need to be done for each
package and are discussed in the next section, @ref{Control Files}.


@node Control Files, Obtaining, Infrastructure, The Library Maintainer View
@subsection Control Files

Each package source must contain a number of control files in the
top-level directory.  These files in general can be created and then
ignored, except for a few variables that need to be updated when new
versions are released.  In most cases even adding, renaming, and
removing library source files can be handled by generic rules.

The package control files include

@table @file
@item Makefile
Must set a few @file{make} variables used by the administrative
utilities, and defines a couple of package-building targets to depend on
appropriate targets defined generically in @file{XEmacs.rules}.  It may
also provide various variables and rules to transform the source tree
structure into that expected by the run-time system.

@item package-info.in
Provides a template for package information to be provided to the
administrative utilities.  Static variables that are rarely changed
(such as the package's name) are entered as literals.  Some variables
are generated by the build process (build dates and MD5 checksums) and
are automatically filled in.  Finally, some variables that change
irregularly (dependences and even version numbers) are set as
@file{make} variables in the @file{Makefile}.

@item ChangeLog
Not strictly required, but normally a ChangeLog will be added by the
XEmacs package maintainer if different from the upstream maintainer.

@item _pkg.el
Generated.  Simply does a @code{package-provide} for the package.

@item auto-autoloads.el
Generated.  Read when XEmacs is initialized, and provides autoloads for
defuns and other forms in the sources that are marked with an
@dfn{autoload cookie} (@samp{;;;###autoload}.

@item custom-loads.el
Generated.  Read when XEmacs is initialized, and informs the Customize
subsystem how to find the defcustom forms needed to create Customization
forms for the usre configuration variables of the package.
@end table


@node Obtaining, , Control Files, The Library Maintainer View
@subsection Obtaining the @value{xpms} and Required Utilities

Currently both the infrastructure for creating XEmacs packages and the
package sources themselves are available only by CVS.  See
@uref{http://www.xemacs.org/Develop/cvsaccess.html} for more
intformation.

The @value{xpms} currently requires GNU @file{make}, and XEmacs, to build
packages.


@node The Package Release Engineer View, , The Library Maintainer View, Package Overview
@subsection The Package Release Engineer View

The XEmacs Package Release Engineer is responsible for keeping the
system coherent.  The changes to @file{packages/package-compile.el} and
@file{packages/xemacs-packages/Makefile} required to make the package
available to others, and for building SUMO tarballs, @emph{etc}, are
done by the Package Release Engineer, not individual library
maintainers.

The Package Release Engineer also maintains assorted infrastructure for
actually making releases.  These are generally available for inspection
in the @code{xemacs-builds} module in the CVS repository.

@c #### To be completed.


@node Package Terminology, Building Packages, Package Overview, Packaging
@comment  node-name,  next,  previous,  up
@heading Package Terminology:

@subsection Libraries and Packages
@cindex library
@cindex package

A Lisp @dfn{library} is a single loadable file containing Lisp code.  It
may be in source or byte-compiled form.  A Lisp @dfn{package} is a set
of one or more libraries, usually related to each other in some way,
bundled with administrative information for convenient distribution.

@subsection Package Flavors

There are two main flavors of packages.

@table @strong
@item Regular Packages
@cindex regular package
A regular package is a set of Lisp libraries design to cooperate with
one another.  A very complex example is Gnus.  One may not in general
safely remove any of the component libraries.

@item Single-File Packages
@cindex single-file package
A single-file package is a collection of thematically related but
otherwise independent Lisp libraries.  These libraries are bundled
together for convenience of the maintainers.  Usually individual
libraries may be deleted at will without any loss of functionality of
other libraries in the package.  However, we would recommend that you
follow this rule of thumb: "When in doubt, don't delete".  If it's
really that big a deal, request that the maintainers split the package
into smaller aggregations.
@end table

@subsection Package Distributions
@cindex package distributions
@cindex binary packages
@cindex source packages
XEmacs Lisp packages are distributed in two ways.  @dfn{Binary packages}
are used by system administrators and end users.  They are packaged in a
form convenient for direct installation into an XEmacs package
hierarchy.  @dfn{Source packages} are for developers and include all
files necessary for rebuilding byte-compiled lisp and creating tarballs
for distribution or installation.  This is all of the package author's
source code plus all of the files necessary to build distribution
tarballs (Unix Tar format files, gzipped for space savings).
(Occasionally sources that are not relevant to XEmacs are usually
renamed to @file{file.upstream}.)

Currently, source packages are only available via CVS.  See
@url{http://www.xemacs.org/Develop/cvsaccess.html} for details.

The package distributions are also split according to major features
required in XEmacs to support them.  At present there are @dfn{generic}
packages, which can be loaded by @emph{any} XEmacs, and @dfn{Mule}
packages, which @emph{require} Mule support or they will cause errors
when loaded.  Note that there is no guarantee that a generic package
will have any useful functionality in a minimally configured XEmacs.  As
long as any XEmacs can successfully load the package's libraries
(perhaps given other required Lisp libraries), it will be classified as
generic.  At the present time only Mule packages need be treated
specially, and even those only if they contain multibyte characters.


@node Building Packages, Makefile Targets, Package Terminology, Packaging
@comment  node-name,  next,  previous,  up
@cindex building packages
@cindex package building
@heading Building Packages:
Currently, source packages are only available via anonymous CVS.  See
@url{http://www.xemacs.org/Develop/cvsaccess.html} for details of
checking out the @file{packages} module.

@subsection Prerequisites for Building Source Packages

@table @code
@item GNU cp
@item GNU install 
(or a BSD compatible install program).
@item GNU make 
(3.79 or later preferred).
@item makeinfo 
(4.2 from texinfo-4.2)
@item GNU tar
(or equivalent).
@item GNU gzip
(or equivalent).
@item A properly configured @file{Local.rules} file.
@ref{Local.rules File}.
@end table

And of course, XEmacs, 21.0 or higher.

@section What You Can Do With Source Packages

The packages CVS sources are most useful for creating XEmacs package
tarballs for installation into your own XEmacs installations or for
distributing to others.

It should be noted that most of the package @file{Makefile}s do
@emph{not} need to contain @emph{any} target rules.  Everything is
handled from the @file{XEmacs.rules} file, located in the toplevel
directory of the packages source tree.


@node Makefile Targets, Local.rules File, Building Packages, Packaging
@cindex package makefile targets
@chapter @file{Makefile} targets
The following targets can be used when running @code{make} to build the
packages: 

@table @samp
@item mostlyclean
Removes any documentation files that have been processed by @TeX{}.

@item clean
Does a @code{mostlyclean}, plus removes generated postscript and dvi
files.  Also removes any generated .elc files, along with the normal
.elc files in the package and HTML and .info files.

@item distclean
Use this when preparing a distribution.  It kills anything that can be
rebuilt. 

@item extraclean
Does a @code{distclean} and also removes any backup files (@file{*~})
and @file{core} files.

@item package-info
Creates the @file{package-info} file from the @file{package-info.in} and
writes an entry in the @file{package-index} file.

@item bindist
Builds the package, including any Texinfo documentation (info format),
writes an entry into the @file{package-index} file and builds a tarball
of the package.  Also writes an entry into @file{setup-packages.ini}
which is later used in the creation of netinstaller's @file{setup.ini}.

@item install
Builds and installs a package

@item install-only
Doesn't build anything, just installs it.

@item autoloads
Generate the package's @file{auto-autoloads.el} file.

@item binkit
Creates the directories needed for installation and copies the files
there.  Basically this is an alias for @code{install-only}.

@item html
Builds the HTML versions of the documentation.

@item compile
Does most of the work.  Builds the elcs, infos at a minimum.
@end table

@section The targets that most people would be interested in would be:

@itemize @bullet
@item @code{all}
@item @code{bindist}
@item @code{html}
@item @code{install}
@item @code{install-only}
@item @code{clean}
@item @code{distclean}
@end itemize


@node Local.rules File, Creating Packages, Makefile Targets, Packaging
@comment  node-name,  next,  previous,  up
@cindex local.rules
@heading The Local.rules File:
This file in @file{packages} provides the @value{xpms} with information about
the local configuration and environment.  To create @file{Local.rules},
simply copy @file{Local.rules.template} from that directory to
@file{Local.rules} and edit it to suit your needs.

These are the variables in @file{Local.rules} that you may need to
provide values for:

@table @samp
@item XEMACS
The name (and path if needed) of the XEmacs binary to use for building
the packages.  The default is @code{xemacs}.

@item XEMACS_21_5
This will enable some, as yet, unimplemented features in XEmacs 21.5 and
above.  For now leave this blank (the default) regardless of the XEmacs
version you are using.

@item BUILD_WITHOUT_MULE
Set this to @samp{t} if you are using a non-Mule XEmacs.  The default is
that this variable is not set (blank) which means to build @emph{with}
Mule. 

@item XEMACS_NATIVE_NT
Set this to @samp{t} if you are using a native Microsoft Windows build
of XEmacs (not a Cygwin build) to build the packages.
@strong{N.B.} To Windows users, you still need the Cygwin environment to
actually build the packages.

@item XEMACS_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT
Set this to the root of where you want the packages to be installed.
Under this directory will hang @file{xemacs-packages} and
@file{mule-packages}.  See @code{NONMULE_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT} and
@code{MULE_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT}.  The default for this is
@file{/usr/local/lib/xemacs}.  Which may not be what you want if you are
developing XEmacs.  To quote the comments in
@file{Local.rules.template}:

@quotation
If you are developing XEmacs, you probably don't want to install the
packages under /usr/local, which is where the stable, released version
of XEmacs goes.  Instead, we suggest a layout as described in the base
README file of recent versions of XEmacs.  In a nutshell, we suggest
you put your source under /src/xemacs, and under this put the package
sources in package-src/, and the installed packages in xemacs-packages/
and mule-packages/.  If you do everything this way, you might want to
set things as follows:

XEMACS_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT = $@{XEMACS_PACKAGES_BASE@}/..

which puts the xemacs-packages/ and mule-packages/ directories as sisters
of the package-src/ directory, and you have to tell configure the location
of the installed packages using `--package-path', something like

configure --package-path=/src/xemacs/xemacs-packages;/src/xemacs/mule-packages
@end quotation

@item symlink
The default is unset (blank).  If you set this to @samp{t} then
@code{make install} will create a @dfn{symlink farm} of the installed
packages under @code{XEMACS_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT}.  Obviously, for
this to work, your system has to support symbolic links.  This is as
close as you can get to @dfn{running in place} for the packages.

@item NONMULE_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT
This is where the non-Mule packages get installed to.  The default is
@file{$@{XEMACS_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT@}/xemacs-packages}. 

@item MULE_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT
This is where the Mule packages get installed to.  The default is
@file{$@{XEMACS_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT@}/mule-packages}. 

@item NONMULE_PACKAGES
A whitespace separated list of non-Mule packages to build/install.

@example
NONMULE_PACKAGES = bbdb gnus xemacs-base prog-modes
@end example

The value for this variable can also be the symbol
@samp{xemacs-packages}, which means to build/install @emph{all} of the
non-Mule packages.  The default is @samp{xemacs-packages}.

@item MULE_PACKAGES
A whitespace separated list of Mule packages to build/install.

@example
MULE_PACKAGES = mule-base leim locale
@end example

The value for this variable can also be the symbol
@samp{mule-packages}, which means to build/install @emph{all} of the
Mule packages.  The default is @samp{mule-packages}.

@item PACKAGE_INDEX
The name of the package-index file.  The default is @file{package-index}
and you probably don't need to worry about changing it.

@item INSTALL
The path to a BSD compatible install program.  The default is
@code{install -c}.

@item TAR
The path to GNU/tar.  The default is @code{tar}.

@item BZIP2
The path to the bzip2 compression program.  The default is unset
(blank).  If this is set @file{.tar.bz2} archives will be built 
@emph{in addition to} the @file{.tar.gz} archives.

@item EXCLUDES
For things that you @emph{don't} want to go into the package tarballs.
It takes the same format as GNU/tar's @code{--exclude} option.  The
default is:

@example
EXCLUDES =					\
	--exclude 'CVS'				\
	--exclude 'RCS'				\
	--exclude 'SCCS'			\
	--exclude '*~'				\
	--exclude '*.orig'			\
	--exclude '*.rej'			\
	--exclude '.\#*'
@end example

@item VANILLA
Set to the XEmacs command line option that forces running in
@dfn{vanilla} mode.  The default is @samp{-vanilla}.  You wouldn't ever
need to alter this.

@item BATCH
How to put XEmacs into @dfn{batch} mode.  It also sets a couple of other
things and in the normal course of events you wouldn't need to alter
this from the default which is:

@example
BATCH = $(VANILLA) -batch -eval \
        '(setq stack-trace-on-error t \
               load-always-display-messages t \
               load-ignore-out-of-date-elc-files t \
               load-show-full-path-in-messages t)'
@end example

@item MAKEINFO
The path to @code{makeinfo}.  The default is @samp{makeinfo}

@item INSTALL_HTML
Set this to @samp{t} if you want to install HTML versions of the Texinfo
documentation.  The default is unset (blank).

@item TEXI2HTML
The path to the program that can convert Texinfo source to HTML.  The
default is @code{texi2html}.

@item TEXI2DVI
The path to the program that can convert Texinfo source to DVI.  The
default is @code{texi2dvi}

@item DVIPS
The path to the program that can convert DVI to Postscript.  The default
is @code{dvips}

@item TEXI2PDF
The path to the program that can convert Texinfo source to PDF format.
The default is @code{texi2pdf}.

@item TEX
The path to @TeX{}.  The default is @code{tex}

@item MSGFMT
The path to msgfmt.  The default is @code{msgfmt}

@item RCOPY
The path to your copy command (GNU cp).  The default is dependent on
whether or not @var{symlink} is set (@samp{t}).

If @var{symlink} is unset (blank), @code{RCOPY}'s default is 
@code{cp -af}.  If @var{symlink} is set (@samp{t}), @code{RCOPY}'s
default is @code{cp --force --recursive --symbolic-link}.
@end table

It should be noted that in most cases the defaults should be fine.  Most
people will probably only need to alter:

@itemize @bullet
@item @code{XEMACS_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT}
@item @code{NONMULE_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT}
@item @code{MULE_INSTALLED_PACKAGES_ROOT}
@item @code{NONMULE_PACKAGES}
@item @code{MULE_PACKAGES}
@end itemize

@node Creating Packages, Documenting Packages, Local.rules File, Packaging
@comment  node-name,  next,  previous,  up
@cindex creating packages
@chapter Creating Packages:
Creating a package from an existing Lisp library is not very difficult.

In addition to the Lisp libraries themselves, you need a
@ref{package-info.in} file and a simple @ref{Makefile}.  The rest is
done by @file{XEmacs.rules}, part of the packaging system
infrastructure.

@menu
* package-info.in::             package-info.in
* Makefile::                    @file{Makefile}
@end menu

@node package-info.in, Makefile,,Creating Packages
@chapter package-info.in
@cindex package-info.in
@cindex package-info
@file{package-info.in} contains information that gets injected into the
@file{package-index} file when @code{make bindist} is run.  Here is a
real world example from the xemacs-base package (a description of each
field follows the example):

@example
(xemacs-base
  (standards-version 1.1
   version VERSION
   author-version AUTHOR_VERSION
   date DATE
   build-date BUILD_DATE
   maintainer MAINTAINER
   distribution xemacs
   priority high
   category CATEGORY
   dump nil
   description "Fundamental XEmacs support, you almost certainly need this."
   filename FILENAME
   md5sum MD5SUM
   size SIZE
   provides (add-log advice-preload advice annotations assoc case-table chistory comint-xemacs comint compile debug ebuff-menu echistory edmacro ehelp electric enriched env facemenu ffap helper imenu iso-syntax macros novice outline passwd pp regexp-opt regi ring shell skeleton sort thing time-stamp timezone tq xbm-button xpm-button)
   requires (REQUIRES)
   type regular
))
@end example

@subheading Description of the Fields in @file{package-info.in}:
@table @samp
@item NAME
The name of the package.  In the case of the example it is
@samp{xemacs-base}. 

@item standards-version
Part of the internal package infrastructure, its value should always be
@samp{1.1}.  Do not change this.

@item version
This is the XEmacs package version number of the package.  It is set
from the @file{Makefile} variable @code{VERSION}.  This is something
that the XEmacs Package Release Engineer deals with so there is no need
for a package maintainer to touch it.  In @file{package-info.in} just
put the place-marker, @samp{VERSION} here.

@item author-version
This is the package's internal, or @samp{upstream} version number if it
has one.  It is set from the @file{Makefile} variable
@code{AUTHOR_VERSION}. 

@item date
This is the date of the last change made to the package.  It is
auto-generated at build time, taken from the package's toplevel
@file{ChangeLog}. 

@item build-date
The date the package was built.  It is auto-generated.

@item maintainer
This is the name and email address of the package's maintainer.  It is
taken from the @file{Makefile} variable @code{MAINTAINER}.

@item distribution
An unused field, leave as @samp{xemacs}

@item priority
An unused field, can be any of @samp{high}, @samp{medium}, or
@samp{low}. 

@item category
The @samp{category} of the package.  It is taken from the
@file{Makefile} variable @code{CATEGORY} and can be either
@samp{standard} for non-Mule packages, or @samp{mule} for Mule
packages.  The is also provision for @samp{unsupported} in this field
which would be for packages that XEmacs.org do not distribute.

@strong{N.B.} As yet, the @value{xpms} does @emph{not} support this type of
package.  It will in the future.

@item dump
Unused.  Always @samp{nil}

@item description
A free form short description of the package.

@item filename
The file name of the package's binary tarball.  It is generated at build
time by @code{make bindist}.

@item md5sum
The MD5 message digest of the package's binary tarball.  Generated at
build time by @code{make bindist}.

@item size
The size in bytes of the package's binary tarball.  Generated at build
time. 

@item provides
A whitespace separated list of @emph{all} the features the package
provides.  Surround the list with parens.

@item requires
Taken from the @file{Makefile} variable @code{REQUIRES}.  It is a list
of all the package's dependencies, including any macros and defstructs
that need to be inlined.

@samp{REQUIRES} cannot be correctly computed from the calls to
@code{require} in the package's library sources.  @samp{REQUIRES} is
used to ensure that all macro and defstruct definitions used by the
package are available at build time.  This is not merely a matter of
efficiency, to get the expansions inlined.  In fact, it is
@emph{impossible} to call a macro by name in byte-compiled Emacs Lisp
code.  Thus, if the macro expansion is not inlined, the call will result
in an error at run-time!  Thus, packages providing libraries that would
be loaded because of autoload definitions must also be included.

@item type
Can either be @samp{regular} for a regular package, or
@samp{single-file} for a single file package.

@strong{N.B.} This doesn't refer to the number of lisp files in a
package.  A single-file package can have multiple lisp files in it.
@xref{Package Terminology}.
@end table

The fields in @file{package-info.in} that need to be changed directly
are:

@itemize @bullet
@item NAME
@item description
@item provides
@item type
@end itemize

Everything else is either set from the appropriate @file{Makefile}
variable, is auto-generated at build time, or is static.

@node Makefile,,package-info.in,Creating Packages
@chapter @file{Makefile}
@cindex Makefile, package
@cindex package Makefile
The @file{Makefile} is quite stylized.  The idea is similar to an
@file{Imakefile} or an @code{automake} file: the complexity is hidden in
generic rules files, in this case the @file{XEmacs.rules} include file
in the top directory of the packages hierarchy.

It is important to note that the XEmacs used to compile packages is
the bare minimum: it is called with the @samp{-no-autoloads}.  This
means that anything not dumped into XEmacs by default needs to be
specified in the @samp{REQUIRES} variable (for packaged Lisp) or in
some cases the @samp{PRELOADS} (autoloads used in libraries mentioned
in @samp{PRELOADS}).

There isn't much to an @value{xpms} @file{Makefile}, basically it just
contains a few @file{Makefile} variables and that's it.  See the
example. 

Here is a real world example, from the @samp{build} package:

@example
# Makefile for build lisp code

# This file is part of XEmacs.
# 
# XEmacs is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify it
# under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the
# Free Software Foundation, either version 3 of the License, or (at your
# option) any later version.
# 
# XEmacs is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but WITHOUT
# ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or
# FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the GNU General Public License
# for more details.
# 
# You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
# along with XEmacs.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.

# For the time being, remove MULE_ELCS from the all dependencies if
# building without Mule.

VERSION = 1.10
AUTHOR_VERSION = 2.02
MAINTAINER = Adrian Aichner <adrian@@xemacs.org>
PACKAGE = build
PKG_TYPE = regular
REQUIRES = xemacs-base pcl-cvs dired w3 prog-modes
CATEGORY = standard

ELCS = build.elc build-report.elc

STANDARD_DOCS = t

include ../../XEmacs.rules
@end example

Most packages don't need any more than what you see above.  It is
usually @emph{not} necessary to specify any special @file{Makefile}
rules.  Everything is handled from the @file{*.rules} files in the
toplevel of the package source hierarchy.

Of course, with that said, there are always exceptions to the rule.  If
you think that your package will need some special @file{Makefile}
hackery contact the @email{xemacs-beta@@xemacs.org, XEmacs developers}.
We distribute over 100 packages so the chances are good that you won't
be the first to need such hackery and it is probably already catered
for. 

@subheading @file{Makefile} Variables Explained:
A number of @file{make} variables are defined by the @value{xpms}.  Some are
required, others are optional.  Of course your @file{Makefile} may
define other variables for private use, but you should be careful not to
choose names that conflict with variables defined and used by the
@value{xpms}.

The required variables are described in the table below.
The corresponding field names for @file{package-info.in}, where
relevant, are given in parentheses.

@c This is the canonical place for this information.  If there is
@c unnecessary duplication with package-info.in documentation, shorten
@c that and leave this full-length.
@table @samp
@item VERSION
(version)
The version of the XEmacs package, a numeric literal (a decimal
fixed-point number with two-places of precision).  The only person who
ever needs to touch this is the XEmacs Packages Release Engineer.

@item AUTHOR_VERSION
(author-version)
The upstream author's version, an uninterpreted literal.

@item MAINTAINER
(maintainer)
A literal containing the XEmacs package's maintainer and his/her email
address.

@item PACKAGE
The name of the package, a literal

@item PKG_TYPE
The type of package, a literal containing either @samp{regular} for
regular packages, or @samp{single-file} for single-file packages.  This
should feed the @samp{type} field in @file{package-info.in}, but
currently it doesn't.

@strong{N.B.} @samp{single-file} here does @emph{not} refer to the
number of lisp files in a package. @xref{Package Terminology}.

@item CATEGORY
(category)
A literal, either @samp{standard} or @samp{mule}.  The non-Mule packages
are @samp{standard} and the Mule packages are, you guessed it,
@samp{mule}.  This field is used at package installation time as part of
the process of determining where a package should be installed to.

@item REQUIRES
(requires)
A list of packages required to correctly build this package.

Note that the usual form in @file{package-info.in} already has the
parentheses, so the @file{make} variable should be set to a
space-separated list of package names @emph{not} enclosed in
parentheses.

The list is of @emph{packages}, not @emph{libraries}, as would
ordinarily be provided to the Lisp @code{require} function.

@samp{REQUIRES} cannot be correctly computed from the calls to
@code{require} in the package's library sources.  @samp{REQUIRES} is
used to ensure that all macro and defstruct definitions used by the
package are available at build time.  This is not merely a matter of
efficiency, to get the expansions inlined.  In fact, it is
@emph{impossible} to call a macro by name in byte-compiled Emacs Lisp
code.  Thus, if the macro expansion is not inlined, the call will result
in an error at run-time!  Thus, packages providing libraries that would
be loaded because of autoload definitions must also be included.

@item ELCS
The list of the byte-compiled Lisp files used by the package.  These
files and their @file{.el} versions will be included in the binary
package.  This variable determines which libraries will be
byte-compiled.  These libraries are also deleted by @samp{make clean}.

Note there is no sanity-checking done on this variable.  If you put
@samp{.el} files in here, they will not be compiled and they @emph{will}
be deleted by @samp{make clean}.  You would surely be very distressed if
that happened, so be very careful.  If this variable is left empty, none
of your Lisp code will be compiled or packaged.  This would be a less
than amusing surprise, too.

We don't consider this a feature, of course.  Please do submit code to
do sanity checking to @email{xemacs-patches@@xemacs.org}.
@end table

Optional, but commonly used variables are explained below.

@table @samp
@item ELCS_1
A list of extra byte-compiled Lisp files used by the package to be
installed in a subdirectory of the package's lisp directory.  The same
care should be taken with this as with @code{ELCS} in regard to
@code{make clean}.

@item ELCS_1_DEST
The name of the subdirectory for the @code{ELCS_1} files to be installed
to.  Be sure to include @samp{$(PACKAGE)/} as part of the name.

@example
ELCS_1_DEST = $(PACKAGE)/extra
@end example

Would put the @code{ELCS_1} files for the package, @samp{foo} into
@file{xemacs-packages/lisp/foo/extra/}.

@item EARLY_GENERATED_LISP
For additional @file{.el} files that will be generated before any
byte-compiling happens.  Use this for @samp{autoload-type} files.  You
must write @file{Makefile} rules to build these files.

@item GENERATED_LISP
For additional @file{.el} files that will be generated at
byte-compilation time.  You must write @file{Makefile} rules to build
these files.

@item PRELOADS 
This is used if you need to pass extra command line arguments to
XEmacs to build the package.  For instance, a specification for
loading libraries containing macros before compiling the Lisp in the
package.  This is spliced directly into the invocation of XEmacs for
byte-compilation, so it must contain the @samp{-l} flag for XEmacs:

@example
PRELOADS=-l ./apackage-macros.el -l ../bpackage/lisp/bpackage-macros.el
@end example

Preloads are loaded before @file{package-compile.el}, so the
@code{load-path} is minimal.  Therefore @samp{PRELOADS} must specify a
full path to packaged Lisp.  The base @code{load-path} does include the
core Lisp directory, so core libraries are found.

@item AUTOLOAD_PATH
The subdirectory in the package's source tree where the @file{.el} files
reside.  This is where the @file{auto-autoloads.el} file will be placed.

@strong{N.B.} There is no need to use this variable if the @file{.el}
files are in the package's toplevel directory.  @code{AUTOLOAD_PATH}
defaults to @samp{.}.

@item PACKAGE_SUPPRESS
Place calls to @code{package-suppress} here to indicate Lisp libraries
that should only be available to particular versions of XEmacs.  For
example: 

@example
PACKAGE_SUPPRESS = \
 (package-suppress 'xemacs-base \"regexp-opt\" '(emacs-version>= 21 5 11)) \
 (package-suppress 'xemacs-base \"easy-mmode\" '(emacs-version>= 21 5 11))
@end example

@c Change this when Ben has committed the WS that implements
@c `package-suppress' --SY.
@strong{N.B.} This feature has not yet been implemented in XEmacs yet.
It will appear in an upcoming version of XEmacs 21.5.

@item STANDARD_DOCS
Set this to @samp{t} if your package's Texinfo source file is located in
the package's toplevel directory @emph{and} is named
@file{$(PACKAGE).texi}. 

@item EXPLICIT_DOCS
Use this to explicitly list Texinfo sources that @emph{aren't} in the
package's toplevel directory.  For example:

@example
EXPLICIT_DOCS = texi/$(PACKAGE).texi
@end example

See @code{DOCS_TXI_EXTENSION} and @code{DOCS_TEXINFO_EXTENSION} if you
don't use the @file{.texi} file extension on your Texinfo sources.

@item EXTRA_TEXI_FILES
List here extra Texinfo source files needed to build your
documentation.  Whatever is listed here is passed on to @code{makeinfo}
as a dependency.

@item EXTRA_HTML_FILES
Use this to specify extra @file{.html} files to output.

@item DOCS_TEXINFO_EXTENSION
Set this to @samp{t} if your Texinfo source files have a @samp{.texinfo}
extension.

@item DOCS_TXI_EXTENSION
Set this to @samp{t} if your Texinfo source files have a @samp{.txi}
extension. 

@item EXTRA_DOC_FILES
Files listed here will be installed to @file{.../man/$(PACKAGE)/}.  For
example, you might want to list @TeX{} files or @file{.eps} files here.

@item EXTRA_SOURCES
Other files (such as extra Lisp sources or an upstream @file{Makefile})
that are normally placed in the installed Lisp directory, but not
byte-compiled.  These files are @emph{preserved} by the @samp{clean}
targets.

@item LIBSRC_FILES
For files that need to be installed to @file{lib-src/$(PACKAGE)/}.  If
the files listed here need to be built you will have to write
@file{Makefile} rules to do so.

@item DATA_FILES
Any data files, such as pixmaps, READMEs, and ChangeLogs.  These must be
paths relative to the root of the package's source tree.  These files
will be copied to @samp{$(DATA_DEST)} for installation.  Any directory
component of the path for a file will be stripped, so that the
file ends up in @samp{$(DATA_DEST)}, not in a subdiredtory.

@item DATA_DEST
The directory where the files in @code{DATA_FILES} are installed to.  It
is a subdirectory of the installed @file{etc/} directory.  Be sure to
prefix this value with @samp{$(PACKAGE)}, for example:

@example
DATA_DEST = $(PACKAGE)/foo
@end example

Would put files into @file{.../etc/$(PACKAGE)/foo/}.

@item DATA_1_FILES ... DATA_35_FILES
For data files that need to go into a different directory from
@code{DATA_DEST}. 

@item DATA_1_DEST ... DATA_35_DEST
The name of the subdirectory for files specified in
@code{DATA_@var{n}_FILES}.  And like @code{DATA_DEST}, be sure to prefix
@samp{$(PACKAGE)} to the value of these variables.

@item EXTRA_DEPENDENCIES
For additional files to build that aren't appropriate to place in any
other @file{Makefile} variable.  You will need to write @file{Makefile}
rules to build these files.
@end table

@section @file{package-compile.el}
@cindex package-compile.el
@cindex compiling packages
The @value{xpms} does not automatically become aware of your package simply
because there is a new subtree.  If any package, including your own,
requires any of your files, it must be explicitly added to the compile
environment or loads/requires that search load-path will fail.  The
changes that need to be made are

@table @strong
@item an entry in @code{package-directory-map}
This tells the @value{xpms} which distribution (currently
@samp{xemacs-packages} or @samp{mule-packages}) your package is found
in.  It then looks in the distribution subdirectory whose name is the
same as the package's.

@item an entry in the @code{cond} in @code{package-name-to-directory}
This is optional; it is necessary only if you keep your Lisp code
somewhere other than the top-level directory of the package's source
tree, eg, in @file{packages/xemacs-packages/$(PACKAGE)/lisp}.
@end table

This only needs to be done once, when the package is first added to the
@value{xpms}.  (Well, when you randomly change the subdirectory layout, too.)
Your changes to @file{package-compile.el} must be cleared and checked in
by the XEmacs Package Release Engineer before your package will build
correctly from a fresh checkout.

This is unfortunate; it works pretty well once set up, but can cause
confusion when first building a package in the @value{xpms} context.  In
particular, if the @code{package-directory-map} entry for a required
package, including the package itself, is not found, the necessary
requires will not be executed by @file{package-compile.el}.  If
required functions are executed (under @code{eval-when-compile}),
they won't be found and the compile will fail.  If required function
is actually a macro, the byte compiler will not recognize that,
compile a function call to the macro.  This will cause a run-time
error because the byte-code interpreter does not know how to execute
macros.  (Macros can always be expanded at compile-time, and this is
more efficient.)

If your package keeps some or all Lisp code somewhere other than the top
directory, then an entry in @code{package-name-to-directory} is also
necessary, or requires will fail, leading to the problems just described.

@node Documenting Packages, Issues, Creating Packages, Packaging
@comment  node-name,  next,  previous,  up
@cindex documenting packages
@heading Documenting Packages:

@c #### Add a documentation section to Internals, and xref here.
Some random notes on documenting your package.

Do write a Texinfo file.  It's not that hard to do basically, and even
using the more advanced features of Texinfo soon become natural.  For a
start, just grab the template @file{Samples/package.texi} from the
@value{xpms} source tree, and drop your current README into the Top node.  At
least this way your documentation will be accessible from the standard
Info readers.  Next, try to add lots of cross-referencing and logical
markup, and then node structure.

Address both end users and developer issues.  You may not be the
maintainer forever.

If you are maintaining a package that is part of the GNU Emacs
distribution, you'll likely find that you occasionally synchronize your
package with the GNU Emacs sources.  When you synch a file,
conventionally you should place a comment just above the standard
@code{;;; Code} comment that looks like this:

@example
;; Synched with:
;; GNU Emacs 21.1, 2002-02-08, Stephen Turnbull <stephen@@xemacs.org>
@end example

This comment is a status flag; the ChangeLog doesn't really give the
same information.

Do maintain a detailed ChangeLog.

@node Issues, , Documenting Packages, Packaging
@section Issues

To be completed.